amanico
[JLC Moderator]
401610
Not convinced by the level of finishings of the movement, for a watch of this price, and if I find it good looking and interesting, I would rather go for a Rattrapante 5370P with its enamel dial.
Patek Philippe Ref. 5470P
And for those among us who like a sportier aesthetic and complication, here is the 1/10th of a Second Monopusher Chronograph , ref. 5470P-001 . The platinum case measures 41 x 13.68 mm Blue varnished dial with applied white gold Breguet numerals (I think ...
tbh
that red text on the dial was unnecessary the pusher should have been integrated in the winding crown I tried hard, really hard to count at least some sharp inward angles ... but failed And not a fan of the dial, the newest 5370 on the other hand has a ma...
I share your views, not fond of this watch.
The recent 5370R is much more appealing, even if the subdials are also placed below the 9 to 3 line. Best, Emmanuel ...
and this particular wheel
How they do it here and how they did it ( or still can if they take a bit more effort ) ...
Thank you Bruno for your insights! š
Do you know if the finishing of the 5370R movement is on a higher level? Best Thomas
I'll let Bruno answer, of course, he knows much better than me.
But here are the photos of the CHR 29-535 PS provided by Sjx. Best, Emmanuel credit: Sjx ...
I THINK both are at the same level
Which is good But since the 5470 is close to euro 500k ā¦. It could be better Canāt afford that kind of watches but if I could I would prefer the 5370 ā¦. By far
I'm interested in the 5370 R and on the waiting list at my AD.
I don't know yet if I'll actually buy it. I find all these current prices quite... (sorry) obscene. Ultimately, they're concentrating on fewer and fewer customers and milking them dry. A widespread problem in the watch industry. Just my2c. š
Very sporty indeed and I fully understand the appeal,
even if it's not for me. Best, Emmanuel
I almost always prefer steel for a white metal...
...especially in a 'sporty' watch. Platinum for a thin dress watch...
Same for me.
I guess such a piece isn't made for collectors seeking high-end hand finishing.
True, a bit thick.
This aesthetic is really nice indeed if one likes the sporty look.
I agree with consensus expressed here and I think itis rooted in a more overall problem..
I think this watch is just - ok - but doesnāt get my juices flowing. It is aligned with Pateks overall aesthetic codes or design philosophy. Classical with a twist of modern that feels quite cold and industrial. Itās a shame because PP is an amazing brand...
I can only agree with you, Christian.
All the more so since this sporty aesthetic doesn't speak to me anyway. The 5050P and 1569J are really something else for me... Best, Emmanuel
Hi Emmanuel, this is an attractive watch !š
The 1/10th of a second complication is most amazingšŖ Do not when it might be used thoughš¤£
Fast running hands drive me mad, personally,
so this complication isnāt for me. šµāš«š±š
But of course I understand the appeal for those liking a more sporty aesthetic and complication! š
Yes, spectacular in its own sporty way.
This aesthetic isnāt for me, but I fully understand the appeal and your enthusiasm. Best, Emmanuel
The diamond being between the lugs
you easily forget about it! I understand the appeal of this sporty aesthetic but I donāt feel personally attracted to it (Iām too conservative I know!). Best, Emmanuel
I definitely applaud the decision for the 5 Hz movementā¦
Maybe not my favorite chronograph but it is well proportioned and the sporty aesthetic is reasonably well pulled off šš»
Not for me, nor for someone who wants high-end hand finishing for the very high price,
but definitely appealing for anyone who likes a non-sports watch with a great sporty look. Best, Emmanuel
Like you said a nice and interesting Patek .
Wouldnāt be my choice either if i am in the market for a Patek like this
Not for me either, but I understand the appeal,
even if, as Bruno pointed, the finishing of the movement is not on par with the price. Best, Emmanuel
Beautiful watch.
with a cool and impressive complication. It must be fun watching the red sweep chronograph hand sweeping across the dial.
It's probably very enjoyable if...
you like (ultra) fast running hands. I have to say that they drive me nuts, personally, especially the 'foudroyante' ones. So, definitely not for me (too much activity on the dial as soon as the chronograph is activated), but undoubtedly appealing (even I...
I know what you mean.
I've sold my JLC Duometre QL primarily due to the constant foudroyante second hand... at least you can activate/deactivate it on this one.
That blue dial with the red accents really pops.
Thank you Emmanuel for this wonderful presentation. The photography really captures how that blue varnished dial plays with the light. That red central hand is quite the focal point. I share your feelings about the sporty direction. It is beautifully exec...
Thank you, Bill.
I admire the achievement too. However, as Bruno has noted, the finishing isn't on par with the half a million asking price. Also, as Mike has noted, a steel case (and a lower price) would probably have made more sense since the target seems to be a wealth...
I'm sure you have guessed my opinion about this 5470...
I will not comment on the finishing issue that has been much debated here already (with right imho as I share the concern about this issue) so I will more comment the aesthetic issue. The color combination and global design could have been a good idea for...
I like your way of thinking about this watch.
In fact I agree with you on all counts! ;-) Best, Emmanuel
That dial treatment must be appreciated with at least a 10X loupe!
Such a pretty piece! It gives me huge pride to have the simplest form of this Patek movement in my 5170. Best, Robert
I like your 5170 better, Robert,
and you have all the good reasons to be proud! Best, Emmanuel
I love the aesthetic of this watch.
The dial color is superb, the breguet numerals, the platinum case do not disappoint. I love a sporty watch that n precious metal. Itās a beauty. Thanks for sharing.
My pleasure. This watch isn't my style but I understand the appeal.
That said, as Mike H has suggested, steel would have made the watch more affordable. In platinum the asking price is half a million and, as Bruno pointed out, at this price point you are entitled to expect high-end hand finishing, which isn't the case her...
I am surprised nobody has mentioned the apparent defective dial
Or is this just an image illusion? ...
As I have written in the post "(I think the following photos are more faithful to the texture of the dial than the one below)"
In other terms, I have noticed this problem of course, but I think it's a photographic problem. The next photos show what the dial really looks like. Best, Emmanuel