image

Genealogical studies (II/II): From the Roger Dubuis Hommage to the Excalibur

Ornatus-Mundi
Avatar
Following my recent journey tracking the ancestry of the La Monégasque back from the original Sympathie I would like to hit the road again, this time travelling on the roots of the Excalibur collection, which is the descendant of another foundation collection, the Hommage

none


1.) The original Hommage:

none


The original Hommage was a watch that Mr Dubuis liked to refer to as the reference to the Genevan watchmaking tradition. It should embody all the elements that made this particular school of watchmaking to famous and successful: elegant, timeless designs, superb craftsmanship and distinctive complications.

none

Mr Dubuis selected a conservatively dimensioned 37mm round case as the common denominator (a 40mm version has been introduced later). Dubuis considered such a case is a perfect stage for his own creativity which found its best expression in the distinctive retrograde displays presented by the company.

I chose a very special one, the highly coveted Hommage Triple Retrograde watch with a guilloched mother-of-pearl dial:

none


The watch displays time (hours and minute) on two sectors of a circle in the upper and the date in one on the lower half of the dial.

Isn't the level of detail and the masterful execution simply to die for? The combination of surface structure (here: the specific reflectivity of the MOP) and the engraving patterns demonstrates a deep understanding of dial design.

none


Another aspect very dear to my heart are these wonderfully vintage cathedral hands, individually heat-blued by hand:

none

The picture below is the same watch, just shot from a different angle and with different illumination. The dial suddenly appears brown... Note the wave-shaped guillochage and particularly the delicious blue reflection of the stack of hand-hearts in the centre of the dial:

none


Turning the watch over we see a finely brushed case band with integrated lugs. One area where the further development of the collection can be easily traced is the shape of the concave bezel and its relationship to the diameter and the height of the case:

none


A close-up of the side reveals something rather rarely seen: note that the lugs do not simply evolve from the overall case band, no, there is about 1mm residual case between upper bezel and the top of the lug. A tiny but distinctive detail!

Note also the finely designed crown. In this case it houses a pusher to set the hands.

none


The movement is an automatic movement Cal. RD57, a 25 jewel movement based upon the Lemania 8815 and used in the early days of RD. It comes with 40 h of power reserve (stored in two (!) barrels)) and a most beautiful rotor - a feast for the connoisseur!

none

none


Like all of the RD movements from this era, it features a swan's neck micro adjustment. The prestigious Poinçon de Genève is well visible right of the balance wheel:

none


On-the-wrist-feel? Just look at the pictures, do I have to say more?

none

none



2.) The early 2000s Hommage:

none


In the early 2000 years the Hommage collection was subjected to a significant refresh. While a 40mm version has been introduced already earlier, the overall design had not been altered yet. This changed after after about 7 to 8 years when the design was considerably streamlined in favour of cleaner lines with thinner (both horizontally and vertically) bezel, bolder dial designs, simple but succulent leaf-shaped hands and a larger (43mm) more 'lug-focussed'' case style with over-sized crowns.

I have a (very!) weak spot for this particular era of the Hommage. Its has an almost architectural simplicity in it compared with a boldness that does not wear out. In addition, there are just so many lovely small details to admire. Just look at how the moon phase aperture cuts into the 'VIII' of the hours ring:

none


The hands again have simply a lot of life in them... marvellous!

none

From the side the subtle but effective difference to the older versions comes clear. The bezel is much thinner, the case band thicker and the crown enlarged. The case is still brushed but the lugs no longer.

none


The vertical structure of the brushing pattern brings the pronounced curvature of the case band out quite well.

none


I really love this crown, with a great size to touch it and with a lot of details to admire:

none

This image below says a lot: the watch is all about the lugs, the contrast between brushed and polished surfaces reinforce this impression.

none


On the backside we find a new movement, the RD calibre RD14, now with 33 jewels. 48h of power reserve (up from 40).

none


Its barely visible here, but the outer rim of the rotor carries an engraved hand script reading Mr RD's motto: "Nous souhaitons toujours créer des montres actuelles, inspirées mais pas soumises au passé, qui se projettent dans un futur qui nous appartient" (translation: "We always wish to create timepieces of today, inspired by, but not subject to, the past which projects itself into a future that belongs to everyone"):

none


Here is why I consider this type of RD watch as the epitome of the collection:

none


I think its a design that will stand the test of time. Not too many details, just the right balance in combination with a very strong design. Really, really well done! It comes with only a slight drawback for users with small wrists: the long lugs may come with a comfort penalty for you.

none



3.) The Hommage 45mm:

none


During SIHH 2013 RD reintroduced the Hommage, this time intended as a homage to Mr Roger Dubuis himself. 

none

none


The modifications put the case itself back into the spotlight with redesigned lugs to improve wearing comfort and a bezel with a steeper acclivity:

none


The crown retained is fairly large size and wonderful details and is a (sensual) pleasure to use:

none

Again, also this one is pleasure to wear, also for people with smaller wrists (as Oliver, my wrist model, confirmed):

none

none

If you want to read more on this piece I suggest you click on this link which guides you to a recent article of mine (with lots of images and a video as well!) 

4.) The Excalibur:

This may come as a surprise for many: The Excalibur as descendant of the Hommage! The shape of the case, with its outwards lugs (and an third one to boot!) and the sawtooth bezel?

none


But then, on the dial side, the family traits are all there. The usage of very few but bold details make it a very timeless watch:

none


The finishing touches of the watch are carefully selected sunbursts and radial finishings:

none

I have to applaud RD for paying attention to the correct representation of the different functions of the dial: timekeeping hands (here: red gold) are separated from the stopwatch functions (here: black):

none

The side view gives another indication for its Hommage heritage. Note the shape of the lugs!

none


The pushers are special not only because of their looks, but also because of their grip. 

none


The Excalibur Chrono is driven by a new automatic chronograph calibre RD681 with vertical clutch and micro-rotor. Composed of 280 components, it displays the hours, minutes and small seconds in a dial at 9 o’clock and the date in a window at 6 o’clock. Power reserve is 52h. 

none

Its a great compromise between a classical and unobstructed look of a manual movement and the convenience of automatic winding.

none


The printed rotor inscription:

none


A watch which looks perfectly at home even on smaller wrists (again, Oliver):

none


Time has to tell how the current Hommage and the current Excalibur develop their relation to each other. So far, the former is reserved for higher end complications, e.g. tourbillons and minute repeaters as well as combinations thereof while the latter mainly contains more accessible pieces. Considering the different conceptions this makes a lot of sense: The Excalibur as entry into the RD world with a fresh and young design, and the Hommage for the seasoned collector. One can grow up within the RD world and still follow the very same route.

The question is: where do you stand?

none

Cheers and thanks for reading,
Magnus

P.S.: I did not have the new 45mm Hommage available for the group shot - it was presented just two months after!
 


This message has been edited by Ornatus-Mundi on 2013-10-28 07:19:25

Comments:
Avatar
AnthonyTsai October 28th, 2013-19:28
I'm part of the Excalibur group I consider the Roger Dubuis Excalibur line to be fresh, hip, bold, and ideal for today's modern man. The exploding Arabic numerals are to die for IMO. Cheers, Anthony
Avatar
Ornatus-Mundi November 3rd, 2013-04:32
Anthony, these arabic numerals... are really special one for you - exploding Lapis Lazuli : Cheers, Magnus ... 
Avatar
Mohannad (aka Riddler) October 29th, 2013-04:06
im hooked on Excalibur BUT im very attracted to the 2000s Hommage although they are round but they are not usual i just love the way they look
Avatar
Ornatus-Mundi November 3rd, 2013-04:08
I am also an admirer of the 2000... so clean yet such an amazingly strong design. Cheers, Magnus
Avatar
Sandgroper November 5th, 2013-04:42
Thank you Magnus for this excellent review...... My taste has long been for the Hommage especially the Chronograph Mono-Pusher manual. But I have to say that I am more and more attracted/fascinated by the Micro-Rotors. To me it is the perfect symbiosis between the purity of a manual movement and the pra... 
Avatar
Ornatus-Mundi November 6th, 2013-13:25
Interesting perspective and I certainly agree... except - there was at least one micro-rotor chronograph movement before, and it was even one of the very first automatic chronograph movements ever produced: The Breitling/Heuer/Büren Cal. 11 (image from the internet, all of them): Of course, it lacked th... 
Avatar
Sandgroper November 6th, 2013-15:54
Interesting, thank you Magnus. Good to wake up...... in the morning one learns something:) I had never even heard of such a mouvement. Cheers, Francois
0-10-7

Load More Comments




 Next Article
image
Ornatus-Mundi
Avatar

Fascinating insights into the creation of the outstanding enamel dials at RD...

Ornatus-Mundi
Avatar
was posted almost four years ago by Purist Jonathan Hang (Z3) here on Purists. He revisited the high level and artistry that went into creating exemplary enamel dials. Some experts even suggest that those belong to the best ever created in the industry: Jonathan writes: "While much attention is focused on high complications,miniature enamel painting remains one of the exclusive yet relatively under-appreciated specialty in the Swiss watch industry. One maker that has a special place in my heart is Roger Dubuis ...


Go to top.

About US | Contact

© 2017 - WatchProZine