image

Hands on review of the Harry Winston Midnight Monochrome Automatic

foversta
Avatar
Over time, the Midnight collection has found its place in the Harry Winston catalogue embodying the sleek and elegant style of the brand. One of the first watches of this collection is the Midnight Automatic which has defined the asthetic elements that would be re-used on a regular basis thereafter. The Midnight case with a diameter of 42mm and a thickness of 9mm  has brought indeed a new dimension to Harry Winston being as refined as the Premier case while being more easily approachable. When it was presented at Baselworld 2011, the Midnight Automatic seduced me with its simplicity and delicacy that I found consistent with the spirit of the brand. However, in my mind, a doubt remained: the watch featuring an inert dial, without second hand, maybe there was a risk to become a bit boring in the long run despite its pretty finishes dial?

none



I think Harry Winston became aware of this risk and at the same time of the potential given by the wide surface of the dial. The bezel of the case is pretty thin, the opening and the purity of the dial provide a large area for the expression of alternative decorations bringing the energy and the originality that the watch may need. This is the reason why the Midnight Automatic "Blue" with a white gold case was then unveiled. The reflections of light created by the blue dial are beautiful. They enliven the dial when the wrist moves and they totally offset the lack of the second hand. The blue dial has another virtue: thanks to its dark color, it reduces the perception of size, which in the context of a refined watch with a 42mm diameter is not useless.

The Midnight automatic Blue:


none


The Midnight Monochrome Automatic, which made its first appearance at Baselworld 2013, is part of the same approach but the aesthetic audacity goes beyond. To break the smooth and perhaps too quit style of the dial, Harry Winston created a metallic slate dial impression that literally transforms the atmosphere of the Midnight Automatic.

none



Thanks to its unique and irregular texture, the dial creates a kind of paradox which explains in large part the unique charm of this watch. Indeed the Midnight Monochrome Automatic combines a white gold case which remains very traditional in its presentation with a more singular dial. Harry Winston has yet found the perfect mix: the originality of the metallic slate effect does not fall into eccentricity and its rendering still stays within the criteria of refinement of the brand. Again, they are the shades and the reflections of light that alter the appearance of the dial which becomes more or less dark depending on the moves of the wrist. Irregularities can clearly be seen as virtually disappear.

The metallic slate impression is enhanced by the simplicity of the Midnight Monochrome Automatic. Applied indexes and logo are sufficiently discrete to avoid overloading on the dial. The Midnight hands are as usual beautiful, very thin and with character. Perhaps my only real regret lies in the date window. In such a context, maybe it would have been better to remove it to fully preserve the surface dedicated to the metallic slate effect. Its presence is however not shocking even if a dark date disk would have been preferable.

none



Without any surprise, the caseback  displays the same movement than with the other versions of the Midnight Auto. The Girard-Perregaux caliber GP3300 is a reliable and effective movement with a 4hz frequency  and a power reserve of 45 hours. I appreciate its winding efficiency and its simple decoration that matches the spirit of the watch. However, it always has a contained diameter (26.2 mm) and it seems a bit  lost in the case. A solid caseback would have been a better option.

The dark color of the metallic slate impression reduces the perception of size:


none



The Midnight Monochrome Automatic is a watch that after the first feeling of surprise, seduces with its controlled originality. The texture of the metallic slate impression proves to be a bold and adapted decoration adapted to the context of the slender and dressed watch. With this new dial, the Midnight Automatic finds a new energy and becomes much more animated than the original version due to light reflections it causes. It is dedicated to customers who look for a classic watch but at the same time with the little touch of character that prevents it from falling into a too rigid style.

none



Thanks to the Harry Winston team for the warm welcome at Baselworld 2013.

Pros:
+ The originality and elegance of the metallic slate dial impression
+ The slender and refined Midnight case
+ The efficiency of the GP3300 movement

Cons:
- The date window seems superfluous in this context
- A solid caseback would have been welcome, despite the pretty gold winding rotor

Comments:
Avatar
MTF October 26th, 2013-16:05
Further thoughts: Harry Winston Midnight Monochrome Automatic FrX, Thank you for the deeply thought and clearly crafted review. That metallic slate-like dial is still mesmerising upon second look after the excitement of the launch. I have been pondering about the see through case back. Whilst understanding your pref... 
Avatar
foversta October 27th, 2013-14:37
Thanks Melvyn for your comments! But you don't have to worry since almost brands follow your advices: even when a solid caseback is obvious, commercial reasons oblige them to put a see-through caseback. ;) Fx
Avatar
KIH October 26th, 2013-18:54
Love the new dial! .. but I wish it were hand wind, date has the same color background. And then, see-through is always welcome. Thanks for your review, FX! I suspect this is rather affordable, right? Best, Ken
Avatar
TOPLIMIT October 26th, 2013-19:34
The dial looks... .... Simply sublime. Gosh. Have been drooling since I saw this, oops! IMO, a see-through case back is a "must have", especially for a watch of this caliber. I don't know if it is only me, but I love to have watches with see-through case back. Once again, ... 
Avatar
foversta October 27th, 2013-14:34
Thanks Robin! The most difficult with the pictures is to get the beautiful shades of light the dial creates. I hope that you will be able to see it in the metal soon. Thanks! Fx
Avatar
foversta October 27th, 2013-14:35
Thanks Ken for your comments. Frankly speaking I don't have the latest price list with me so I prefer to get it before answering you with a bad price. But don't expect a too "affordable" price! Fx
Whirling October 26th, 2013-21:52
Agreed! Love that dial, but... The date really is distracting. It would be best just to remove it, but, as Ken said, matching the color on the date wheel to the dial would certainly help. Also, would it be a crime to add a second hand? How many people dislike second hands? They really ... 
Avatar
foversta October 27th, 2013-14:32
I have mixed feelings with your comments Jon... I do agree with you about the date but I don't feel the need like you about a second hand. I would find it more appropriate with the smooth dials on which an animation is required. Don't forget that maybe a thicker case would be required too... Big thanks... 
Avatar
DRMW October 27th, 2013-01:35
interesting observations... Thanks for the review and impressions of the Midnight. -MW
Avatar
foversta October 27th, 2013-14:30
Dear Ming, Thanks a lot for your constant participation in the Harry Winston forum! Fx
0-10-10

Load More Comments




 Next Article
image
foversta
Avatar

Back to the Midnight Minute Repeater... with a movie!

foversta
Avatar
A few days ago, I had the opportunity to see again the Midnight Minute Repeater in the new Harry Winston boutique located rue de la Paix. This visit gave me the ability to take better pictures of the watch I presented you in July in the hereafter article: In a few words, it is a relevant evolution of a model which was unveiled during the last quarter of 2009. It includes by a very convincing way several aesthetic details which art part of the Midnight Collection style. The new hands are the best evidence ...


Go to top.

About US | Contact

© 2017 - WatchProZine