rishi_77
134
The rose gold for me...
Emmanuel...lets think about how the 5098 P compares to the R version. Similarly..the monochromatic feel is cool, more understated luxury, but the contrast provided by the rose gold version makes the subdials pop. This is a big dial...so I feel the need for the contrast. Both are amazing of course...but I'll go with the rose gold version
Rishi
Ref. 5235: White or Rose gold?
Patek Philippe 's Annual Calendar Regulator was launched in 2012 with a white gold case, ref. 5235G-001 . This initial white gold model was discontinued in 2019 and replaced by a rose gold version, ref. 5235/50R-001 , which is still in the current catalog...
Quite some members here have one…
But also not sure myself if I have ever seen it live 🤷🏻♂️
I am biased But I bought this before the rose gold model came out
The case is similar to ref 3448 But that’s where the similarities end ...
Ah! Great I didn’t realize you had one.
This reference shares the Padellone case with the 3448: www.watchprosite.com I really like the 5235, but not to the point of wanting one and I like the 3448 even more! Best, Emmanuel
The rose gold for me...
Emmanuel...lets think about how the 5098 P compares to the R version. Similarly..the monochromatic feel is cool, more understated luxury, but the contrast provided by the rose gold version makes the subdials pop. This is a big dial...so I feel the need fo...
I find the rose gold variant truly appealing, and I fully understand
what you say about the contrast of the subdials. But I'm not fond of white hands (they look a bit toy-like to me, whatever the model) and I would really need to see the WG in person to get a good sense of how it compares to the RG. Maybe someday! Best, Em...
Oh yes...the white hands do look plastic like!
Could they have done a better job with the apertures on the dial as well? And perhaps trimmed it to at least a 38mm diameter? But I feel they deserve points for the regulator styled execution , and of course the movement design. Simply beautiful! I hope t...
Thank you so much, Rishi!
I am very much looking forward to and enjoying in advance these two days of visiting! I agree with you: the movement design is beautiful and I like the regulator display. Emmanuel
RG for me. The dial is so much more legible and honestly, I think this reference deserves the appearance of a precious metal.
White gold/platinum, although beautiful for me does not convey the richness as yellow or rose gold. I’m sure some people appreciate the fact that the lighter metals are less conspicuous.
I definitely understand your preference and I also find the RG version appealing.
I just don't fully warm up to the white hands which feel a bit toy-like to me (just my personal feeling, of course). And I would really like to see the WG in person someday. Best, Emmanuel
All are very good looking Patek Philippe Annual Calendar Regulator watches.
For me it would be the first watch in the pictures with the slightly darker grey dial and the black sub dials and minute track, it is just the one I find the most visually appealing. Marc
It is really appealing indeed.
I just have a doubt personally concerning the white hands, which can only look a bit toy-like (I mean not as refined as gold or blued hands, at least for me). Best, Emmanuel
For me white gold. The rose gold is more beautiful on pictures,
The white gold fits my skin and style better.
Thank you for your feedback: that's good to know!
I hope to be able to try on the WG someday. Best, Emmanuel
Lucky you! It's a wonderful piece, imo.
One which deserves much more attention than it gets! Best, Emmanuel
Saw the R at the Doha boutique in Place Vendome Mall
Warm and quirky dress watch! What really captivated me was the vertical brushing on the dial. Best, Robert
Thank you for your feedback, this is interesting.
I hope to be able to see the WG in person someday. Best, Emmanuel
White gold all the way for me!
I thought I would prefer the rose gold, but when I saw it in the metal I was disappointed. The case and dial were not harmonious to my eye, and the painted white hands bothered me. The original in white gold is high on my “Want List”.
Like you, the painted white hands bother me.
They feel toy-like to me. I hope to be able to see the WG in person someday. Best, Emmanuel
It’s definitely worth seeing.
Far more understated than the current iteration, in my opinion, and hence works better for me. The new one seems uncomfortably “blingy” in the metal. Very much a matter of personal taste in any case. (Terrible pun!)
My best story about this reference is this -
I was in Sicily summer 2024 staying at San Domenico Palace in Taormina and saw a guy who was completely covered in tattoos swimming in the pool with the RG reference... on a leather strap…. I was so worried about this beautiful microrotor movement …
Yes, appealing.
But I have a personal doubt concerning the white painted hands: I'm not fond of them. Best, Emmanuel
I've only seen it a few times from a bit of a distance....
On the wrist of a client of mine who could easily afford any timepiece, including those sold for millions at auctions.... It certainly speaks volumes that he chose that piece above countless other options. I'd definitely like to examine one in person....
This timepiece mixes the iconic "Padellone" case (coming from the 3448)
with an unusual complication for PP: the regulator. So it is definitely a very special watch.
That's an interesting combination!
I'm personally not sure I like the white painted hands: they feel a little toy-like to me (not this particular execution, but any white painted set of hands tends: I prefer gold or heat-blued hands). Best, Emmanuel
Rose Gold is my favorite as well.
The 5235R has long been my favorite annual calendar from Patek. The combo of rose gold and charcoal/black subdials along with the engraved Patek logo is awesome. I was fortunate enough to try one at Wempe in NYC last summer. Pictured here with my son admi...
This 5235 R is high on my wishlist
I will try to add one when possible although i am slimming down the collection i really like to tick this box
The white gold gets my vote
I've always been drawn to the understated elegance of white gold. There is something about the way it plays with light that just feels more refined to me. The rose gold is beautiful no doubt, but that monochromatic dial on the white gold version has a qui...
You describe very well the impression given by the white gold version
and you make me want to see it in person even more one day! I've only been able to see the rose gold version so far. Best, Emmanuel
Hi Emmanel, I like both but prefer the
G because I like the color scheme which shows the brushed dial prominently !
I’m attracted to the G too,
but haven’t been able to see it in person yet. Hopefully someday. Best, Emmanuel
5235G, but it is close
I have currently the same question and am leaning towards the WG model for my 40th birthday. But it is a close call. What speaks to me from the white gold model: - it is the original version of that reference and looks more technical - It looks more under...
Thank you so much, Thomas, for sharing your detailed thoughts.
This is a wonderful perspective for your 40th birthday. I agree with all your points. My only problem is that I’ve never seen the G in person yet, whereas I’ve tried on the R twice. Until I see the G in the metal, I’ll hold my judgement. But one thing is ...