Mark in Paris
[Purist]
10488
I think it looks very nice
Every person will give a different answer as we've all shaped our tastes differently. There are limits to how big or small it can be but, even it this case, if the owner likes it like that then he shouldn't do otherwise because some people expressed something different.
People tend to have more difficulties in understanding how subjective a matter it is. A standard from a specific period can evolve as well and once people are used to something, they don't change easily.
I think this size looks great on your wrist. Btw, a darker dial or a dial with more elements, more complications, looks also smaller.
Take your time, walk around the AD, watch yourself in a mirror and you will feel if it is good for you or not.
Best, Mark
Honestly.....
Do not pay attention to anyone at all. If it's your dream watch, it is you and only you that matters. Go for it. If it makes you happy, go for it. There are guys on this forum who are obsessed by watch size. The only thing that matters is whether you like...
Well said
Size is no different to shape, material or any other watch property. It's a personal matter of taste. Buying watches is such a personal (even egoistic) pleasure for me. If I like it, can afford it and can get the Mrs to approve it, that's all that matters...
Agree with you, Baron.
Size is a very subjective issue. I wear watches from 36mm to 45mm. The most important question is: Does the watch make me smile?
Baron, I got your point! Thank you.
I am worrying about the fit of the bracelet, will that fit my wrist after I remove all the links or it will still be loose? Anyway I will try to sort it out!
Perhaps that looks a bit big on your wrist
but still totally acceptable. Patek 5712 is a great watch and if you really like it, go for that! Best, Kari
What Baron says is spot on. Your wrist can and should carry any watch (regardless of size) that makes you happy. If it is your dream watch, that is all that matters.
Style should be a form of self expression, rather than adherence to the aesthetic sensibilities of others. (So, even though my opinion is irrelevant, I like the way it looks on your wrist. ) Best, patekova.
My dream watch too,
but don't worry too much just about the looks, be sure that you find it comfortable on your wrist. If it does not feel really good on your wrist, don't do it. A watch in this price category should fit like a glove. Gorgeous looking it is, most of us will ...
It is a personal opinion
My wrist is exactly the same size as yours. I personally don't like the watch edges to extend beyond my wrist but I don't mind it too much if it is edge to edge on the wrist, a bit like what you have shown here. In my opinion it looks a little bit big on ...
You say it is your dream watch
hence it tells a lot about your appeal for it. As a few members said already, we are often influenced on forums but you are the one who will live with the watch. The only thing is about how comfortable it is for you, sometimes we might feel that bigger wa...
If you think it feels right it is. Works well on your wrist in my opinion! And typically pictures make it look bigger than it looks in real life because of the angle.
I have a thin wrist too so size is a familiar dilemma for me (although I did not have the pleasure of debating something as amazing as your potential future Nautilus). When I bought watches which were outside my comfort zone size-wise, they felt "normal" ...
Honestly, this is boderline to my eyes...seems large, but it is a very thin watch, so perhaps it wears OK.
If you are in love, and it is comfortable to wear, go for it.
A Patek Philippe is for a strong willed person...
And a strong willed person ought to make his or her own decision! This isn't a decision by a committee, this is a personal watch for you, to be decided by you! I'm not a "Fashion Policeman" but the watch looks fine on your wrist to my eyes. One last thing...
"Dream big" they say ...
If you see it as a classic watch then it is rather big, but as a sports model no issues at all.
Go for it. Buy it. Its not so huge on your wrist.
Its not an alarm clock on your wrist. Here is mine. You will enjoy the watch. Cheers. ...
I noticed
that you say it is one of your dream watches so I am wondering what the other dreams watches are and is size important to you. For me if you love a watch, buy it and do not care too much what others may think. I have a larger wrist than you (6.25 inches) ...
So many wise advices here !
First, listen to YOUR heart ! Of course it is normal to ask to have confidence in YOUR taste and choice ! It happens that you are Lucky : whatever you decide there is no risk : either you wait and the only risk is to pay a bit more... or you pull the trig...
Looks alright from the pic
As wrist shots tend to "enlarge" the watch, I think this one is ok for u.. bear in mind that the watch is accompanying you as a whole so it won't be look nearly as big as when you focus on the watch in a wrist shot.. Also the watch is 40 from 1 to 7.. as ...
Wow I didn't expect so many response overnight! Thank you for all your kind comments!
During my short watch loving life I was always annoyed by my small wrist (goodbye Royal Oak...). I think I'm still in a learning process of how to get rid of it. Back to the 5712, I believe it is pretty much the largest watch I could pull off without havi...
And I am worrying about the fit of the bracelet...
Will it still be loose on my wrist after all links are removed? As a matter of fact I never had watch with bracelet.
My opinion doesn't matter...
But in my experience, when someone asks about size they already know the answer...
I also think that your tailored cuff makes it appear larger.
It accentuates the size of the watch. A looser cuff might help and draw less attention to the wrist size.
Celebrate!
Watches on that level are an object of art and celebration! If it speaks to your heart, then get it, and wear it with joy. Not only will it function as a superb timekeeper, that watch will make you smile. Beautiful, beautiful piece.
This is only a guide not a rule to obey
The diameter of the case is not so important, the distance from the tip of the lugs at 6 to tip of the lugs at 12 are more important. The tips of the lugs should not stick out of the profile of the wrist- again that is just a guide only. Some lugs (like o...
Far too big
In my view, a watch should cover 2/3 or 3/4 of the "wrist space". The watch you showed covers all of your wrist. This watch might be too big for you. Dont hesitate to consider the currently unpopular 33-36mm Pateks, there might be some bargains. Dont foll...
Most interesting view Tony!
Many may disagree with you based on the many wrist shots we see but I am in agreement with you. Then again, if someone does love a watch even if it is massive HYT, then , hey who are we to stop him from living his dream?!
He asked for our opinon, right?
Noone is going to stop him from buying the watch. But the OP's post was a question, how we see the quite large watch in relation to his own wrist, as shown in the pic. Poky also said something very wise about diameter and lugs. I think, in my very persona...
Agree
Looks much better viewed from a distance with loose cuffs. What's the size difference between this watch and the first one? Maybe the OP could revisit the dream watch?
I think it looks very nice
Every person will give a different answer as we've all shaped our tastes differently. There are limits to how big or small it can be but, even it this case, if the owner likes it like that then he shouldn't do otherwise because some people expressed somet...
you make an interesting point....
.....regarding how hard some find it to think beyond their own preferences as "fact". Take the concept that a watch "should" cover 2/3 to 3/4 of wrist space. As far as I know, there is no scientific fact to this view. It is just one person's subjective vi...
Well
The OP asked for opinions, not for agreement. I am sure the opinions of anonymous internet strangers will not prevent him from buying that Nautilus. I, in my very subjective opinion which is purely subjective, think that given his wrists, a Nautlius is sl...
The golden ratio....
....is actually something that has been observed in nature for hundreds of years. Entire sections of financial markets have been swayed by it. It has been observed across nature... Interestingly, it is just an observation rather than a scientific fact. An...
As I said....
1. He asked for our opinion 2. Mine is not going to prevent him from buying the watch 3. I think its too big 4. Several refs (3796 etc) would look ace on him 5. This is just the internet, no need to get upset
none of which has anything to do with my comment to you on the Golden Ratio.
Again, I am making the point that the Golden Ratio is not a scientific rule. Nor is it something that can be readily applied to something where personal and subjective taste is a crucial factor in determining. Your assertion of what is or is not an accept...
again.....
...I am not talking about what the OP asked for. I am talking about the validity of "your truth" and its basis (or lack of it) in science. When one makes assertions as if they are fact, and when those assertions are directed as advice as if factually-driv...
People ask for opinions on forums
but not necessarily subjective, they want the objective way too, as Joe said, because the point is to be able to choose well in the end. Just giving a very partial opinion as if it was a standard truth is misleading. For instance saying that someone shoul...
Well said.
I complete agree. Beauty is certainly in the eye of the beholder. Having said that I think that this new photo looks fantastic.
For me...
....the main issue with wrist size is actually the bracelet and clasp. With small wrists, like mine, it is sometimes difficult to get a proper fit, esp when the links or deployant are larger. Just a case of trial and error (and self discipline to tear you...
Looks good..
As I said wristshots can't be misleading.. the nautilus does wear smaller due to the case shape.. So should be fine
Based on this second photo, the R looks...
more appropriate than the steel version ! good luck with your decision !
Looks good, Musigny82!
Nice jacket, btw! As for the Nautilus, have you by any chance considered the 5800? It is a 38mm time and date only Nautilus which might be perfect for what you have in mind. Not to say that the 5712 isn´t, but just something that addresses the watch size ...
Others opinions matter
So many on this site say get what makes you happy. Yes, certainly, no argument there, but none on this site can say others opinions are not influential or do not influence a decision. Or else why are we on this site? Simply posting on this site has indica...
As far as I can see....
....Musigny dealt with the multitude of opinions that he solicited with great diplomacy and style. He acted like a gentleman. Can you please clarify what you mean by your comment? Where is there evidence to the contrary?
I think it looks fine.
I was going to suggest looking for a 3712 if you like the look of the 5712 but find it a little too big. However looking at the price difference I would stick to the 5712.
Whats more important is the question?
If a watch is purely something to be worn as a display of wealth then you could argue the bigger and shinier the better. If the main purpose is to look elegant then you would want something in proportion with your wrist. If it is a celebration of the engi...
i would have to add qualifications here......
.....we just cannot know why some people like a specific type of watch, or not. You suggest that "bigger and shinier" is commensurate with wanting to display wealth. It may be. or it may not be. Maybe someone who likes bigger and shinier has no interest a...
Dear all, first I would like to thank you again for all your advises, opinions and contribution for my humble potential purchase...
I noticed that this post had encouraged some interesting debates and exchanges, which I found very helpful. I felt like I have learnt a lot just by reading your ideas and responses. I believe a friendly and open-minded discussion is what makes this forum ...
Musigny....
.....you have acted like a gentleman throughout. And you are correct, this forum has its reputation in being friendly and open-minded..... Debate can be vigorous.....and debate will happen. But a very clear message needs to be sent regarding debate when i...
Load More Comments >>